Title:
Effects of Artificial Saliva Contamination on the Shear Bond Strength of Different Orthodontic Adhesive Systems
Author(s):
Laksiree Laohanant,
Supassara Sirabanchongkran, Wikanda Khemaleelakul, Janya Apisariyakul, Dhirawat Jotikasthira
Keyword(s):
Artificial saliva contamination, shear bond strength, Orthodontic adhesivesystem
Abstract:
The purpose of this study was to compare the shear bond strength of different
adhesive systems for bonding orthodontic brackets under non-contaminated and artificial
saliva-contaminated conditions. One hundred and sixty maxillary first premolars were
divided into eight groups of twenty. Stainless steel brackets were bonded using one of
the following adhesive systems: conventional adhesive system (TransbondTM XT), or
moisture-resistant adhesive systems (TransbondTM Plus Color Change, Beauty Ortho
Bond® and Assure®) on both non-contaminated and artificial saliva-contaminated enamel.
Shear bond strength was measured using an Instron® Universal Testing Machine. Analysis
of variance and Tukey’s test were used to compare the differences in the mean values.
The results show that the mean shear bond strength of TransbondTM XT under noncontaminated
conditions (11.70±3.14 MPa) was significantly superior to that of the other
systems, both under non-contaminated and artificial saliva-contaminated conditions (p
< .05), whereas the mean shear bond strength of TransbondTM XT under artificial salivacontaminated
conditions (7.24±1.86 MPa), TransbondTM Plus Color Change under noncontaminated
and artificial saliva-contaminated conditions (7.37±1.59 and 6.44±1.40 MPa,
respectively), Beauty Ortho Bond® under non-contaminated and artificial salivacontaminated
conditions (6.28±2.05 and 6.66±2.01 MPa, respectively), and Assure®
under non-contaminated and artificial saliva-contaminated conditions (6.74±1.61 and
7.28±1.06 MPa, respectively) were not significantly different. In conclusion, artificial saliva
contamination significantly decreased the mean shear bond strength of TransbondTM XT,
but did not affect the mean shear bond strength of the other systems. Nevertheless, the
mean shear bond strength of all systems was greater than 6 MPa, which is clinically
acceptable for bonding orthodontic brackets.